/biz/ - Business & Finance

>>49533029
The problem is the inability to see the "big picture", as Americans like to say. Your argument is that it's possible to look at a transaction in monero, and if it had a specific characteristic of being withdrawn from an exchange and redeposited after 10 blocks, an observer working with the exchange could assign a "privacy score" to that specific transaction. And consequently, that is the same thing that Blockchair is doing.
It seems clear to me that you either can't understand the implications this has on bitcoin, that is unaffected on monero, or you're playing dumb for some reason.
Flagging transactions in bitcoin allows the outputs and addresses belonging in such a transaction to be tracked ad infinitum and that score might or might not have an impact. The same is not applicable in monero (even in the proposed scenario), and so the implications for user privacy are vastly different. So private institutions creating their own scores is something bad for the users in the long run and they should be aware of it, and no, you can't do the same on monero, it would clearly not be "basically the exact same thing", lol.