[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/3/ - 3DCG

View post   
File: 2.95 MB, 1920x1080, 1656043875198.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
905028 No.905028 [Reply] [Original]

Can you spot what is wrong?

>> No.905030

yeah it's soi wars

>> No.905031

wtf are those random explosions and why are they mirrored

>> No.905032

>>905031

also how would the little ship just maneuver like that.. how did this retarded shit get so popular?

>> No.905035 [DELETED] 

>>905028
Where's the background Disney?
Did you forget to lash the animators again?

>> No.905036

>>905028
Can those big destroyers really turn on a sixpence. I thought they used to be slower.

>> No.905053

>>905032
>also how would the little ship just maneuver like that.
Advanced sci-fi engines can generate thrust against the Aether. That makes it look like it's traveling through an atmosphere and generating lift with wings.

>> No.905054

>>905028
since when lasers stop at random and just go poof?

>> No.905057
File: 2.26 MB, 1920x2156, 1656091566475.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
905057

>>905028

>> No.905058

>>905031
>>905054
i'm guessing the lasers are hitting some sort of counter measures that are too small for to picked up on screen? it looks real dumb

>> No.905059

>>905058
>too small to be* picked up on screen

>> No.905062

>>905031
>>905054
>>905058
>>905059
It's probably meant to be a flak cannon

>> No.905063

>>905028
Fire in space?

>> No.905066

>>905057
This is the answer. Why doesn't lighting change on destroyer even though it's turning? Probably because they used blender.

>> No.905084

>>905066
It is changing slightly as it turns. You can see the shadows change near the end, BUT the camera is doing most of the turn. its an optical illusion.

>> No.905088

>>905053
No that's not the problem, the ship is going faster than the speed of light. No star wars ship has manage to outrun a laser, they always do something like spin or get lucky that the laser did not hit them because stormtroopers suck at aiming.

Also the ship is like a planet so it went way faster than normal in that speed.

>> No.905094
File: 2.91 MB, 1920x1080, 0001-0377.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
905094

>>905057

>> No.905105
File: 132 KB, 1502x852, tarded.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
905105

In the sea of bad cg you choose to put work into this?

>> No.905106

>>905105
That's the Rogue One model

>> No.905107

>>905084
The stars do not move, what do you mean the camera is turning?

>> No.905126

>>905028
There's nothing wrong with it. Star Destroyer turns towards camera, shadows all seem correct. It's even more correct than on film as this webm is silent, it's perfect.

>> No.905186

>>905126
except the huge ship that is big as a planet moved faster than normal and the small ship went faster than light. No star wars ship has ever did this, this ruins space logic fantasy.

>> No.905205

>>905186
In universe a Star Destroyer is 1.6km long. About five times longer than this carrier https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziCvqZIyjto

Way it moves seems appropriate for a warship of that size. I can buy that people forward and aft could survive the maneuvers depicted.

>> No.905215

>>905205
1 mile is not the correct size, if you compare it to older star wars scenes you can see that it is bigger than 1 mile because the rebels fight it with their ships. Also there is another ship inside the ship, which means it is way bigger than 1 mile. The one mile you got was maybe from disney version because i seen a lot of people say 1 mile to the disney moves but fail to fit many of the historical features that comes with it under 1 mile.

>> No.905241

>>905028
Lighting of the Star Destroyer doesn't change as it moves.
The smaller ship doesn't obey inertia.

>> No.905250

>>905028
There are shadows that move on the ship when it turns, so it's likely an artistic decision to have the left part of the ship in shadow the entire time. Not commenting on whether it's a good decision or not.
Either that, or the lighting is at some kind of angle that is hard to nail down and is playing tricks since we can't see where it's coming from.

>> No.905444

>>905215
>>905186

...are you retarded? It seems like you're retarded.

>> No.905446

>>905028
Baked lighting

>> No.905482

>>905028
the empire built a destroyer without gimbaled weapon mounts.
but the reason the lighting doesn't change is likely a compositional choice

>> No.905494

>>905444
One mile is not the right size or are you confuse as to what 1 mile is in your metric size because either way you are still wrong.

>> No.905498

>>905028
The small ship and the destroyer are lit independently of one another.

>> No.905499

>>905498
They're not. Post a frame where this allegedly happens - you can't because there is none.

>> No.905505
File: 1.19 MB, 400x400, 1381520516775.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
905505

>>905028
They're not shooting a large AOE explosive that will hit an entire area. Wasting resources on small precision lasers.

Also, not deploying TIEs to intercept.

>> No.905513

>>905058
nah, SW has always explosive lasers because reasons.

>> No.905532

They are fighting in a black void
>inb4 space is a black void

>> No.905547

>>905513
Not that anon, and I know they've always had em, which I'm fine with, but damn those explosions look actually retarded. Like the same 2d sprite each time and for some reason blows away in the vacuum of space.

>> No.905601

>>905057
I thought that too but the shadows do spread a little, maybe not as much as is necessary though.

>> No.907988

>>905028
Aah yess I can spot it! Oh you...

>> No.907993
File: 304 KB, 680x800, 1656102032137.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
907993

>>905057

>> No.908000

>>907993
Kek

>> No.908233

>>907993
heh

>> No.908253

>>905107
That's because the stars are either a flat image composited in, or are set to always face the camera

>> No.908310

>>907993
Lmao

>> No.909863

>>905028
Maybe it's a stylistic choice, faggot

>> No.910029

>>905028
Obviously, I can't remember the way every space scene in the films was filmed, but I feel like they wouldn't have made this scene so long or they would have done it from another angle.
The way how the small ship is running from the star destroyer and seems to be able to outrun it but for some reason was right above it, in the beginning kinda reminds me of video game cutscenes, like that one in Star Wars Clone Wars game where Obi-wan and Anakin are flying their fighters in the middle of empty space but suddenly they notice a separatist fleet right in front of them when the camera angle changes to reveal them.